Immediate Steps When Implicated in a Medicolegal Issue
For Doctors
- Prioritize Patient Care: Provide
lifesaving medical treatment first, regardless of the medicolegal context
or patient's ability to pay.
- Identify Medicolegal Case (MLC):
Assess whether the case, such as unnatural injuries, poisoning, sexual
assault, or unexplained death, requires legal scrutiny or police
involvement.
- Timely Police Intimation:
Notify the local police (often via telephone and in writing) as soon as an
MLC is identified or after immediate patient stabilization.
- Record Comprehensive Medical Notes:
- Use proper forms, avoid abbreviations, and initial any
corrections.
- Record all patient details—personal info, time/date of reporting,
and history
- Preserve Evidence: Do
not discard clothing, personal effects, or any material that may have
forensic relevance.
- Maintain Professional Conduct:
Communicate clearly and compassionately with the patient and their
relatives.
High Courts can grant relief for breaches of both legal and constitutional rights under Article 226.
Section 438 CrPC has been replaced by Section 482 BNSS - provides for "anticipatory bail." It allows a person who apprehends arrest for a non-bailable offence to approach the Sessions Court or High Court for pre-arrest bail.
IPC Section 211(BNS 222) : Deals with "False charge of offense made with intent to injure." It punishes anyone who institutes false criminal proceedings against a person with intent to cause injury
For
Hospital Administration
- Ensure MLC Protocols:
Enforce policies for accurate identification, documentation, and reporting
of MLCs.
- Documentation & Storage: All
medicolegal documents must be carefully stored, usually for a minimum of
10 years.
- Regular Staff Training:
Conduct regular education sessions on medicolegal procedures, consent
protocols, and ethical practices.
- IPD/OPD Registration Procedures:
Emergency departments must assign hospital registration numbers to all
MLCs and inform police accordingly.
- Acknowledge Police Reporting:
Obtain and keep police acknowledgment receipts for all notifications.
- Magistrate Involvement: In
case of a dying patient, inform the magistrate for possible 'dying
declaration' recording
- Compliance with Legal Standards:
Ensure alignment with all relevant Indian healthcare laws and local
regulations.
Legal
Safeguards & Protections for Doctors
|
Legal Safeguard |
Description |
|
Professional Indemnity Insurance |
Covers monetary compensation against claims for medical negligence. |
|
Documented Informed Consent |
Always take informed consent before procedures to reduce liability. |
|
Good Medical Records |
Keep clear, contemporaneous, legible records supporting clinical
decisions. |
|
Adherence to Professional Ethics |
Follow the NMC(Indian Medical Council’s)code of professional conduct and
ethics. |
|
Vicarious Liability Protections |
Hospitals (employers) may be liable for acts of their employees;
doctors can defend by proving due care. |
|
Legal Counsel Access |
Right to a fair hearing and the possibility of representation during
inquiries or legal proceedings. |
|
Protection from Violence |
Several state and central laws criminalize violence against healthcare
professionals, with stringent penalties. |
|
No Immediate Arrest for Negligence |
Supreme Court guidelines suggest no routine arrest for alleged
negligence unless there is evidence of gross negligence. |
|
Reporting Mechanism |
Laws require medical institutions to promptly report incidents of
violence or threats to the police. |
Key Legal
and Regulatory Frameworks
- Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette, and
Ethics) Regulations, 2002:
Defines medical duties, ethical practices, and safeguards doctors against
unfair prosecution.
- Consumer Protection Act (as amended): Patients may hold doctors liable for deficiency in service but
doctors can defend with proof of adherence to standard protocols.
- Healthcare Service Personnel and Clinical Establishments
(Prohibition of Violence and Damage to Property) Act / Central Protection
Act (CPA): Criminalizes violence against healthcare
workers, offering legal protection and obligatory police action.
- Criminal Laws (IPC/BNS):
Doctors must report certain incidents (e.g., suspected homicide,
unexplained deaths) to police to avoid penal consequences.
- Supreme Court Directives:
Doctors should not hesitate to provide care to accident/MLC patients and
need not fear legal harassment provided they act in good faith.
Best
Practices to Avoid and Handle Medicolegal Trouble
- Communicate Clearly: Good
communication with patients and families can prevent misunderstandings.
- Follow Established Protocols: Apply
standard treatment protocols and seek second opinions when in doubt.
- Seek Prompt Legal Advice: If
implicated, consult a medical lawyer.
- Update Knowledge: Stay
informed about current medical laws through journals, workshops, and CME
programs.
Comments
Post a Comment