Is it financially viable for small 10 bed hospital to have empanelment of Ayushman Bharat scheme with Present (very low) packages as reimbursement?
The financial viability of a small 10-bed hospital participating in the Ayushman Bharat-Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (AB-PMJAY) scheme with low reimbursement packages depends on several factors, including operational costs, patient volume, infrastructure, and the hospital's ability to manage resources efficiently. Below is an analysis based on available information and critical considerations:
- AB-PMJAY offers fixed Health Benefit Packages (HBPs) for secondary and tertiary care procedures, with reimbursement rates often lower than private market rates. For example, rates for procedures like cataract surgery or appendectomy may range from ₹5,000 to ₹20,000, which may not cover the full cost of treatment in some cases, especially for small hospitals with limited economies of scale.
- Small hospitals with high fixed costs (e.g., staff salaries, equipment maintenance, utilities) may struggle to break even if reimbursements do not align with actual expenses. Studies suggest that reimbursement rates under PM-JAY are sometimes perceived as inadequate by private providers, leading to cost-cutting measures that can affect quality or profitability.
- A 10-bed hospital typically has lean operations but still incurs costs for doctors, nurses, diagnostics, drugs, and infrastructure maintenance. If the hospital is in a rural or semi-urban area, costs may be lower, but so is the patient footfall, reducing revenue potential.
- Empanelment requires meeting PM-JAY standards (e.g., infrastructure, staffing, and quality protocols), which may necessitate upfront investments. For a small hospital, these compliance costs can strain finances, especially if patient volumes are low.
- Financial viability hinges on sufficient patient volume to offset low margins. PM-JAY can increase footfall by attracting eligible beneficiaries (over 55 crore individuals covered, targeting the bottom 40% of the population). However, in rural areas, awareness and access to the scheme may limit utilization.
- The case mix matters: high-volume, low-complexity procedures (e.g., deliveries, minor surgeries) may be more viable than complex cases requiring specialized care, which small hospitals may not be equipped to handle.
- PM-JAY provides cashless treatment, with reimbursements processed by State Health Agencies (SHAs). However, delays in claim processing (reportedly 30–90 days or more in some states) can disrupt cash flow, a critical issue for small hospitals with limited working capital.
- Claim rejection rates (due to documentation errors or non-covered services) can further reduce revenue.
- Small hospitals often rely on non-PMJAY patients (paying out-of-pocket or through private insurance) to cross-subsidize low-margin PM-JAY cases. If a hospital primarily serves PM-JAY patients due to its location or demographic, this strategy may not be feasible.
- Offering additional services (e.g., diagnostics, pharmacy) to non-PMJAY patients can boost revenue but requires careful cost management.
- In underserved areas, PM-JAY empanelment can give a small hospital a competitive edge by attracting patients who would otherwise seek public facilities. However, in areas with multiple empanelled hospitals, competition may drive down profitability.
- Rural hospitals may benefit from lower operational costs but face challenges like staff shortages and limited infrastructure, impacting their ability to meet PM-JAY standards.
Potential Benefits of Empanelment
- Increased Patient Footfall: PM-JAY can drive demand, especially in areas with high poverty or limited healthcare access, improving bed occupancy rates.
- Social Impact and Branding: Empanelment enhances a hospital’s reputation, potentially attracting more private patients.
- Government Support: Some states offer incentives (e.g., subsidies, tax benefits) to empanelled hospitals, though these vary widely.
- Economies of Scale: High patient volumes can reduce per-unit costs, but this is less achievable for a 10-bed facility.
- Profit Margins: Low reimbursement rates and high operational costs can result in thin or negative margins, especially for complex procedures.
- Upfront Investment: Meeting empanelment criteria (e.g., NABH accreditation, IT systems for claims) requires capital that small hospitals may lack.
- Dependence on PM-JAY: Over-reliance on PM-JAY patients can expose hospitals to financial risks if reimbursement rates are revised downward or payments are delayed.
- Quality vs. Cost: Maintaining quality care under cost pressure may lead to compromises, affecting patient outcomes and hospital reputation.
Critical Analysis
- Empirical Evidence: Limited studies specifically address 10-bed hospitals, but broader analyses of PM-JAY suggest private hospitals with 25–50 beds often find empanelment viable only with high patient volumes or cross-subsidization. For smaller setups, viability is questionable unless costs are tightly controlled.
- Sustainability: The scheme’s design assumes increased demand will improve infrastructure (e.g., via reinvested reimbursements), but small hospitals may lack the capacity to scale up without external funding.
- Alternative Models: Some small hospitals adopt hybrid models, combining PM-JAY with other schemes (e.g., ESIC, state-specific programs) or private patients, to diversify revenue.
Recommendations for Financial Viability
1. Cost Optimization:
- Streamline operations (e.g., use generic drugs, energy-efficient equipment).
- Hire multi-skilled staff to reduce payroll costs.
2. Focus on High-Volume Procedures:
- Prioritize low-cost, high-demand procedures (e.g., cataract surgery, normal deliveries) to maximize reimbursements.
3. Revenue Diversification:
- Attract non-PMJAY patients through OPD services, diagnostics, or pharmacy.
- Explore tie-ups with other schemes like ESIC for additional revenue.[](https://nha.gov.in/PM-JAY)
4. Efficient Claim Management:
- Invest in training for accurate claim documentation to minimize rejections.
- Monitor payment cycles and follow up with SHAs to reduce delays.
5. Community Outreach:
- Increase awareness of PM-JAY benefits in the local community to boost patient footfall.
6. Government Advocacy:
- Engage with SHAs to advocate for revised reimbursement rates or faster claim processing.
In the next post we will explore additional data on reimbursement rates or case studies of small hospitals under PM-JAY?
Comments
Post a Comment